Best Practices for Writing Peer Reviews Be Specific and Actionable Vague feedback like “you're doing a good job” or “you need to improve” doesn't help the recipient. Balance Positives and Constructive Feedback ... Focus on Behaviors, Not Personalities ... Offer Solutions, Not Just Criticism ... Be Timely
1. “I appreciate how you always listen to our ideas and encourage open communication within the team. It makes us feel valued and respected.” Highlighting this behaviour reinforces its positive impact on team morale.
"I appreciate the way you collaborate with your team and cross-functionally to find solutions to problems." "You're an effective team member, as demonstrated by your willingness to help out and contribute as required." "Sarah is a true team player who always helps out her colleagues.
What should I include in 360 feedback? Start by recognizing their strengths and positive qualities, highlighting specific areas of excellence. Identify specific areas for improvement and offer constructive feedback for their development. Provide behavioral examples for your observations.
Positive Peer Review Feedback Examples His ability to take initiative in resolving team conflicts is commendable.” “Sarah is a great collaborator. She always listens carefully during brainstorming sessions and brings creative ideas that help the team move forward.”
360 Degree Feedback Examples for Decision-Making “The team appreciates how David carefully considers all perspectives before making important decisions that impact the organization.” “Samantha could improve her decision-making by making more decisive choices and communicating the rationale behind them to the team.”
What should I include in 360 feedback? Start by recognizing their strengths and positive qualities, highlighting specific areas of excellence. Identify specific areas for improvement and offer constructive feedback for their development. Provide behavioral examples for your observations.
Positive Feedback examples “I appreciate how you always listen to our ideas and encourage open communication within the team. “Your ability to stay calm under pressure sets a great example for the rest of us. “The way you break down complex projects into manageable tasks is incredibly helpful.
Positive peer feedback is just as important for the learning process. Start the conversation with positive notes and then mix in the constructive feedback. If their weaknesses happen to be one of your strengths, it's okay to offer help. It's also important to not beat around the bush and be direct with your comments.
Tips on peer reviewing Do the authors relate their findings to other relevant research in this field/area? Is there relevant research that is missing? Do the authors discuss the limitations of the current study? Do the authors recommend areas for future research? Does this paper fit the overall theme of the journal?