Once you put a settlement on the record, you cannot change your mind unless there were misrepresentations made to you and you relied on those representations to enter into the settlement agreement.
There is absolutely no difference scorewise between paying in full or settling for less, so it's almost always better to accept settlement offers if available. There are a few cases where paying in full may be the better option, but not many.
File a Lawsuit If negotiations fail, filing a lawsuit may be necessary. Courts expect parties to attempt out-of-court settlements first. A solid case showing the insurance company's likely loss in court can bring them back to the negotiation table.
I am writing in response to the settlement offer you presented on Settlement Offer Date, related to claim number Claim Number for the incident that occurred on Incident Date. After careful consideration, I must reject this offer as it does not meet my needs based on the severity and ongoing nature of my injuries.
Extended Claims Process: Declining an offer can lengthen the resolution process, which may be challenging if immediate financial needs are pressing. Possible Legal Action: If negotiations don't yield a satisfactory offer, a lawsuit may become necessary, requiring additional time and resources.
After careful consideration of my financial situation, I am offering to settle this debt for (Proposed Settlement Amount), which is (Specify the Percentage, eg, 50%) of the total outstanding balance. I believe this is a fair and reasonable offer given my circumstances.
I am writing in response to the settlement offer you presented on Settlement Offer Date, related to claim number Claim Number for the incident that occurred on Incident Date. After careful consideration, I must reject this offer as it does not meet my needs based on the severity and ongoing nature of my injuries.
This letter should state: That you will not accept the initial settlement offer; The reasons why you feel you deserve a higher settlement amount; Each of their low-offer reasons, and your responses; The higher settlement amount that you will accept.
You Are Not Obligated to Accept a Settlement Agreement No one can force you to accept a settlement, and you should always choose your best course of action, even if it means rejecting a contract agreement.
Countering a Low Insurance Settlement Offer State that the offer you received is unacceptable. Refute any statements in the adjustor's letter that are inaccurate and damaging to your claim. Re-state an acceptable figure. Explain why your counteroffer is appropriate, including the reasons behind your general damage demands.