The consequences of being charged with criminal defamation, rather than sued in terms of civil law, are significant. First, the accused person has to go through the rigors of a criminal prosecution, which may include arrest and detention and a harrowing criminal trial.
If a person is found guilty of defamation in South Africa, they may face civil liability. The consequences can include: Damages: The defamed individual may be awarded financial compensation for the harm done to their reputation. The court will assess the extent of the harm and the appropriate amount of damages.
Truth, or substantial truth, is a complete defense to a claim of defamation.
The amount of damages is assessed on the basis of the extent of the damage to your reputation. If for instance, the defamation published to only one or two persons, the damage to your reputation may be very slight, in which case the damages awarded to you will be low.
What does a defamed person need to prove in court? publication of a statement (verbal and/or written); the defamer must intend to defame a person; there must be harm or injury; and. the publication must violate a person's right to his/her good name, reputation and dignity.
(ii) There is no set maximum amount of damages that a court will order but the general bracket of damages awards in recent years for publications to the public is between ZAR200 000 and ZAR500 000.
All statements, written or spoken about you, which diminish your reputation in the eyes of right-thinking people, and which were made with that intention, will give you grounds for an action for damages for defamation.
Generally, to prove defamation, you must show that a false statement was made, about you, to third parties, and which caused you damage. Once you have evaluated your case, and determined that you can satisfy these elements, you can then proceed with pursuing your matter.
These include: There must be a defamatory statement. The defamatory statement must be understood by right-thinking or reasonable minded persons as referring to the plaintiff. There must be a publication of the defamatory statement, that is to say, it must be communicated to some person other than the plaintiff himself.
To win a defamation case, the following elements must be proven: Falsity: The statement made must be false. Publication or Communication: The statement must have been made known to third parties. Malice: The statement must have been made with malice or ill intent.