The bond between a lawyer and a client is built on trust and honesty. But what if that trust is broken? Can I sue my lawyer for lying? In some instances, yes, you can sue your lawyer for lying.
If opposing counsel has seriously lied to and misled the court, you certainly should bring it to the court's attention. However, there is a proper way to do that. Example: If opposing counsel misstates an appellate opinion, and you know it is intentional, don't call opposing counsel a liar.
If you find yourself in a situation where you believe the opposing counsel is not being truthful, the key is to rely on evidence and legal procedures to address the issue. You can also consult with a local lawyer in the area of law your case involves to get additional advice on your specific case and this magistrate.
If I have a procedural question such as “Do you know where that exhibit is?” I will directly address opposing counsel as Mr. or Ms. If it is not on the record, we generally call each other by our first names when we know each other from prior cases or experiences, or are friends.
If the problem persists, take action before the situation gets worse. Do not pass the issue to someone else in your office. Instead, a frank exchange between you and the opposing counsel may be needed. Perhaps a colleague can serve as an intermediary to smooth the way to a better relationship.
Misrepresentation. 1 A lawyer is required to be truthful when dealing with others on a client's behalf, but generally has no affirmative duty to inform an opposing party of relevant facts. A misrepresentation can occur if the lawyer incorporates or affirms a statement of another person that the lawyer knows is false.
Tell your clients they're going to have doubts about the quality of your representation and the fairness of the process. Help the clients understand that opposing counsel is acting in an effort to have that impact. Explain that opposing counsel's bad behavior undermines confidence in you, and that's the intent.
Do not engage. Think of her as a course hazard more than an opponent. Aim your words, always, at the judge. Be on time, be reasonable, be flexible to the extent it will not prejudice or harm your client, and do your best to keep all interactions in writing and on the record.
If you find yourself in a situation where you believe the opposing counsel is not being truthful, the key is to rely on evidence and legal procedures to address the issue. You can also consult with a local lawyer in the area of law your case involves to get additional advice on your specific case and this magistrate.
Generally speaking, in the US, an opposing attorney does not owe you a duty that would give rise to a claim for legal malpractice. You might have some other claim against them, but not malpractice.