Virgin Islands Jury Instruction — 1.1.2 Public Employee First Amendment Claim Discharge — Failure To Promote Political Disloyalty — Key Employee: This Virgin Islands jury instruction refers to a specific legal claim related to public employees in the Virgin Islands who have been discharged or denied a promotion due to their alleged political disloyalty. In this case, the claimant should be designated as a "key employee," which establishes their significance within the public entity. When a public employee alleges that their discharge or failure to promote was based on their exercise of First Amendment rights, specifically for their political beliefs or activities, this jury instruction serves as a guideline for jurors to understand the legal standards involved. Key elements and considerations for this jury instruction may include: 1. First Amendment Claim: The claimant must demonstrate that their political beliefs or activities are protected under the First Amendment of the United States Constitution and are related to a matter of public concern. 2. Political Disloyalty: The claimant should prove that their political beliefs or activities were the motivating factor behind the adverse employment action. It is crucial to establish a direct link between the public entity's decision and the claimant's political disloyalty. 3. Key Employee Status: This instruction applies specifically to individuals classified as "key employees." A key employee refers to an individual who holds a position of significance or influence within the public entity, where their political affiliations may have a substantial impact on their job responsibilities. 4. Failure to Promote: If the claimant alleges non-promotion due to political disloyalty, the instruction explains that the claimant must show they were qualified for the promotion and that their political beliefs impacted the decision. 5. Causation: The jury must determine if there is sufficient evidence to establish a causal connection between the claimant's political disloyalty and their employer's decision to discharge or deny promotion. Potential variations or related instructions may cover different aspects of the claim, such as the burden of proof, the employer's defenses, or the calculation of damages if the claim is successful. It is crucial to consult with legal professionals or refer to the specific Virgin Islands Jurisdiction's instructions to ensure accuracy and appropriateness for a particular case.