Since 1970, the standard of proof in juvenile court is preponderance of the evidence. One of the differences between juvenile courts and adult courts is that juveniles are "adjudicated delinquent" instead of "found guilty."
In 1970, the Supreme Court raised the standard of proof necessary in juvenile court to that required in adult criminal court. In in re Winship (397 U.S. 358), the Court required that juveniles charged with criminal acts be proved “beyond a reasonable doubt” to have committed them.
The 1970 Supreme Court case, In re Winship, ruled on the standard of proof that applies in juvenile court cases. The case holding was that if a minor is charged with conduct that would be considered criminal if committed by an adult, the accused has the right to have their guilt proved beyond a reasonable doubt.
Massachusetts has become the first state in the country to categorically ban life without parole sentences for people under 21 years old. Massachusetts's highest court ruled that its ban on life without parole sentences for youth under 18 also applies to “emerging adults,” through age 20.
The momentum to protect youth rights in the criminal legal system is clear. Twenty-seven states and the District of Columbia have banned life sentences without the possibility of parole for people under 18; in nine additional states, no one is serving life without parole for offenses committed before age 18.
Massachusetts Senate Votes to Raise the Age of Juvenile Jurisdiction to Include 18-Year-Olds. (BOSTON—7/11/2024) Today the Massachusetts Senate voted to raise the age of juvenile jurisdiction to include residents who are 18-years-old.
A parole proceeding is a hearing to determine whether an offender is suitable for release to parole supervision. An example of a life sentence with the possibility of parole is when an offender is sentenced to serve a term of “15 years to life.”
Inmates sentenced to serve life in prison with parole eligibility become eligible for parole after serving 15 years of their sentence in most cases. The Life Sentence Unit (LSU) processes all life sentence hearings.
A juvenile may be prosecuted as a Youthful Offender which allows the judge to sentence the individual as a juvenile or as an adult. A person can be considered a Youthful Offender if he or she committed the offense between the ages of fourteen and eighteen.
Typically, juveniles and young adults are sentenced to 2 to 6 years in the YOS, with a community placement and aftercare provision for the last 6 to 12 months of the sentence.