Manage Comment Paper For Free

You should address each and every comment?either make the change or reject it and justify your choice. Pick your battles wisely: Even if you don't agree with a minor change suggested by a reviewer, it's usually easiest to just make the change. It shows you're open to suggestions.

Providing feedback Clarity: The review was easily read and interpreted by the editor and authors. Helpfulness: Comments were constructive, relevant, and realistic. Thoroughness: ... Timeliness:

A comment paper consists of three parts. After a brief summary of the original paper including the author's name and the paper's title, the second part provides a critical acclaim and potential improvement, which is succeed by some concluding remarks.

Summary Give positive feedback first. ... Briefly summarize what the paper is about and what the findings are. Try to put the findings of the paper into the context of the existing literature and current knowledge. Indicate the significance of the work and if it is novel or mainly confirmatory.

Here are a few tips for providing good, critical feedback: Be specific. ... Ask questions. ... Limit yourself to a reasonable number of critical comments. ... Be aware of the goals the writer had for the piece. ... Don't critique spelling, grammar, or punctuation unless you are an expert.

The following simple structure will help you present your comments in an organized way: Reflect back the paper's main point. ... Discuss the essay's strengths. ... Discuss the paper's weaknesses, focusing on large problems first. ... Type your final comments if possible.

When one writes a comment on a published paper , what is actually the intention of the commenting author ? To point out the mistakes or present complete solution . It is seen that very often commenting author just point the mistakes and does not present the complete solution of the problem. Give your view .

Read carefully and calmly Try not to react emotionally or defensively, even if you disagree with some of the feedback. Remember that the reviewers have invested their time and expertise to help you improve your work, and that they are not trying to attack you personally.

Comments should be used to make additions or clarifications, identify and link to material, and are designed to lead to threaded discussions concerning the content, conclusions, and consequences of a specific article. Authors of all comments will be identified by their PLOS username.

WRITING A FINAL COMMENT Reflect back the paper's main point. By reflecting back your understanding of the argument, you let the student see that you took the paper seriously. ... Discuss the essay's strengths. ... Discuss the paper's weaknesses, focusing on large problems first. ... Type your final comments if possible.